LOGIN  |  SUBSCRIBE  |  ADVERTISE  |  CONTACT US
LEDs MAGAZINEILLUMINATION IN FOCUSSTRATEGIES IN LIGHTTHE LED SHOWSTRATEGIES UNLIMITED
LEDs Magazine
HOMEARTICLESNEWSPRODUCTSBUYERS GUIDEEVENTSMAGAZINENEWSLETTERSJOBSTOPIC CENTERRESOURCE CENTER
 INDUSTRY NEWS
< Previous  |  Next >  |  Contents (October 2011)
Share |
US DOE releases results from Round 13 of Caliper testing
18 Oct 2011
The Round 13 summary report includes photometric performance results for LED and benchmark high-bay luminaires, LED wallpack luminaires and LED and benchmark 2x2-foot troffers.
The US Department of Energy (DOE) has completed Round 13 of product testing through the Solid-State Lighting (SSL) Caliper program. The summary report containing the results is now available for download on the DOE SSL website.

Minimum efficacy and performance spread improved with Round 13 SSL products.
Round 13 efficacy
Round 13 of product testing included three primary focus areas: LED and benchmark high-bay luminaires, LED wallpack luminaires, and LED and benchmark 2x2-foot troffers.

The Round 13 summary report provides an overview of photometric performance results, and compares the results with respect to similar products that use conventional light sources, results from earlier rounds of Caliper testing, and manufacturer ratings.

On average, the Round 13 LED luminaires show a significant improvement in efficacy over LED luminaires tested in 2009 and 2010, with a minimum efficacy close to the average observed in 2009–2010. In addition, the variation in performance across the Round 13 LED luminaires is less than in 2009–2010 products; that is, there were smaller differences between minimum and maximum efficacy (see chart), as well as other parameters.

The Caliper summary report from Round 12 of product testing was published in June, which included SSL recessed downlights, SSL track lights, SSL A-lamps, benchmark 100W incandescent A-lamps and 70-100W halogen equivalents, SSL replacements for linear-fluorescent lamps in high-performance troffers, and SSL and benchmark cove lights.

In April, a Caliper study of retail replacement lamps revealed vast differences among the performance of 33 commercially-available lamps. Detailed individual test reports are now available for that study.

About the Author 
Laura Peters is a Senior Technical Editor with LEDs Magazine.
COMMENTS
Name: really?   Posted: Tue, 25 Oct 2011 17:10
I just reviewed the results for the Caliper 13 testing- specifically the high bay comparison summary. I am very curious how they arrived at 9,782 initial lumens for a 175w pulse start ED28 metal halide. Phillips and the other major manufacturers show an initial lumen output at 16,000 for this lamp drastically raising its efficiency (87 Lpw). Also if you go up to the 350w version (98 Lpw)you get even more efficiency but either the 175 or 350 outperform any LED fixture tested if the correct lumen output is used. I worry about the accuracy of this report.
LINKS
Channels
Programs, Funding, Regional Initiatives
Related Stories
Can LED lamps beat the products they replace? (August 2011)
Author
Laura Peters
Copyright © 2007-2013 PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved. LEDs Magazine is part of PennWell's Technology Group, which also includes:
Designed by Kestrel Web Services